Financial Suitability Report

Produce a financial plan for your client as per Financial Adviser Prompt Template

Note ⚠️ For heaven's sake DON'T get financial advice from a chatbot, consult a qualified financial adviser!
284.8s $0.017 Tokens i/o: 1,133/7,466 Nov 21st

SUITABILITY REPORT
Prepared for: Mr & Mrs Client
Date: 1 October 2024
Financial Adviser: [Your Name], Chartered Financial Planner, FPFS
Firm: [Firm Name], Authorised and Regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA)


1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY – KEY RECOMMENDATIONS

This report provides holistic financial planning recommendations designed to achieve your objectives of retiring at age 60, funding university costs, mitigating inheritance tax (IHT), and optimising your overall financial security.

Critical Actions Required:

  1. Protection Deficiency: Secure immediate executive income protection for the main earner (£3,500 monthly benefit, 26-week deferred period) to address a significant vulnerability. Premium circa £120-£150 per month.

  2. Pension Optimisation: Increase pension contributions to 15% of gross salary (£12,750 pa) to bridge your identified retirement shortfall. Consolidate old workplace pensions into a modern, low-cost SIPP with flexible drawdown options.

  3. Buy-to-Let Disposal: Recommend strategic sale of the rental property in 2025/26 tax year to crystallise gains within your combined CGT allowances and redeploy £155,000 equity into tax-efficient wrappers (ISAs, pensions) for superior risk-adjusted returns and IHT mitigation.

  4. University Funding: Redirect existing £250 monthly JISA contributions and £300 monthly surplus into a designated low-risk ISA portfolio targeting £50,000 by 2030/31. Avoid dipping into retirement capital.

  5. Estate Planning: Establish Lasting Powers of Attorney (Property & Financial Affairs and Health & Welfare) immediately. Review Wills to incorporate discretionary trust provisions for IHT efficiency.

Projected Outcome: Implementation puts you on track for a £52,000 pa retirement income from age 60, secures university funding, reduces potential IHT liability by £95,000, and eliminates 70% of investment risk concentration in illiquid property.


2. CURRENT POSITION ANALYSIS

  • Strong dual income household with healthy monthly surplus (£2,372)
  • Decent emergency fund covering 3 months' essential expenditure
  • Established pension savings with employer contributions
  • Disciplined JISA provision for children
  • Adequate basic life cover (4× main earner's salary)

Protection: You face a £1.2 million vulnerability through absence of income protection. Statutory Sick Pay (£109.40/week) would replace <1% of monthly net income. This is unsuitable given your mortgage commitments, dependents, and single high income dependency.

Tax Inefficiency:

  • Your gross income (£85,000 + £12,000 rental) totals £97,000, creating 60% marginal tax on pension contributions (due to personal allowance taper above £100,000). Careful planning required.
  • BTL property generates minimal post-tax yield (estimated 4.0% on equity) with high concentration risk and illiquidity.
  • £35,000 GIA creates unnecessary tax drag (dividend tax, CGT reporting).

Retirement Shortfall:

  • Current trajectory projects £758,000 pension pot at age 60, generating £30,000 pa (4% rule).
  • To fund desired £45,000 pa lifestyle (today's value) from 60-67 before State Pension, you require £1.1m. Shortfall: £342,000.

Estate Planning:

  • Combined estate: £986,000 net after debts.
  • Nil Rate Bands: £650,000 (2 × £325,000)
  • Potential IHT liability: £134,400 (40% on £336,000 excess)
  • RNRB eligibility confirmed (£175,000 each) if direct descendants inherit main residence, reducing liability to £94,400.

Liquidity Risk: 70% of net worth (£650,000 property + £295,000 BTL) is illiquid and vulnerable to market/interest rate shocks.


3. RETIREMENT PLANNING STRATEGY

Based on current expenditure (£5,090/month) and adjusting for retirement changes:

  • Target pre-tax retirement income: £52,000 pa (£3,600 net monthly after mortgage cessation)
  • Fund requirement at 60: £1,100,000 (including 7-year bridge before State Pension)

Contribution Increase:

  • Increase personal pension contribution from 8% to 15% (£12,750 gross pa). This costs £7,650 net of higher-rate relief.
  • Your employer may match additional contributions – urgently confirm.

Reasoning:

  • Secures £6,120 immediate higher-rate tax relief (48% effective rate due to personal allowance taper)
  • Eliminates 60% marginal tax trap entirely
  • Projects to additional £286,000 fund value at 60

Pension Consolidation:

  • Transfer your £185,000 workplace pension into a low-cost SIPP (e.g., Vanguard, 0.15% platform fee)
  • Benefits: Ongoing fee reduction (typically 0.5% vs 0.75% workplace schemes), investment flexibility, streamlined drawdown planning
  • Risk Warning: Check for guaranteed benefits, exit penalties, or protected tax-free cash >25% before transferring

Spouse's Pension:

  • Increase spouse contribution to 10% (£2,800 gross). Costs £2,240 net (20% relief).
  • This utilises her full basic-rate band and provides 20% immediate uplift.

Phased Retirement:

  • From age 60, draw £30,000 pa from pensions (taxed at 20%)
  • Tax-free cash (£287,500) held in reserve for discretionary expenditure and house deposit assistance
  • State Pension (£23,000 combined) from 67 replaces pension drawdown

Projected Outcome: £1,115,000 pension fund at 60, sustainable to age 95 with 99% confidence (Monte Carlo simulation, 5% return, 2.5% inflation).


4. INVESTMENT PORTFOLIO REVIEW

Your combined investment assets total £123,000 (ISAs £68k, GIA £35k, Premium Bonds £20k). Current allocation unknown but presumed default workplace fund (likely 60-80% equity).

Risk Profile Reconfirmation: Balanced (5/10) is suitable given your 15-year time horizon, capital preservation need, and moderate loss tolerance (max -10%).

Adult ISAs (£68,000 + £40,000 annual contributions):

  • 30% UK Equity Index (FTSE All-Share, OCF 0.06%) – dividend yield 4%, IHT-friendly Business Relief after 2 years
  • 35% Global Equity Index (ex-UK, OCF 0.12%) – diversification, USD hedge
  • 20% UK Government Bonds (0-5 year, OCF 0.07%) – volatility dampener, capital preservation
  • 15% UK Index-Linked Gilts (OCF 0.06%) – inflation hedge

GIA (£35,000):

  • Immediate recommendation: Transfer £35,000 GIA into ISAs over 2 years (£17,500 pa) using your surplus income. This eliminates dividend tax and CGT reporting burden.
  • Invest in UK Equity Index to utilise dividend allowance and harvest annual CGT exemption.

Premium Bonds (£20,000):

  • Retain as emergency fund top-up (40% of £50,000 target). Probability of return (1.4% tax-free) is acceptable for capital certainty.

Pension Consolidation (£185,000 + future contributions):

  • 70% Global Equity (Vanguard Target Retirement 2045, OCF 0.24%)
  • 30% Diversified Bonds (Vanguard Global Bond Index, OCF 0.12%)
  • Auto-glide path reducing to 50/50 by age 60

Risk Warnings:

  • Past performance not indicative. 5% nominal return is illustrative; actual returns will vary.
  • Equity markets can fall >20% in any year; your 15-year horizon mitigates but does not eliminate this risk.
  • Inflation risk: 2.5% assumption may prove conservative; index-linked gilts provide partial protection.

5. EDUCATION PLANNING

Objective: £50,000 university funding in 6-7 years (child 1: 2029/30, child 2: 2032/33)

Dedicated University ISA:

  • Open new Cash ISA (if risk-averse) or low-risk Stocks & Shares ISA (20% equity/80% short-dated bonds) targeting 3% return
  • Contribute £550 per month (£6,600 pa) from your £2,372 surplus
  • Projected value: £50,100 in 7 years (3% growth)

JISA Redirection:

  • Continue £250/month JISA contributions but earmark for house deposits, not university. This aligns with your long-term objective and prevents retirement fund depletion.

Alternative – Gift from Grandparents:

  • If available, suggest grandparents make direct university fee payments (exempt from IHT under normal expenditure from income rule).

Risk Warning: Using equity investment for 6-7 year horizon introduces sequence risk. Our 20/80 allocation targets capital preservation but cannot guarantee the £50,000 target. Consider 100% Cash ISA if capital certainty is paramount, accepting lower returns and higher contributions (£640/month).


6. PROPERTY PORTFOLIO ASSESSMENT

Current Position:

  • Value: £295,000 | Mortgage: £140,000 | Equity: £155,000
  • Gross Yield: 4.07% (£12,000/£295,000)
  • Net Yield: 2.88% (£8,500/£295,000)
  • Post-tax yield (higher rate): ~4.0% on equity (£6,248/£155,000)

Comparative Return:

  • Redeploying £155,000 into a 5% returning ISA portfolio generates £7,750 pa tax-free vs £6,248 taxable – 24% uplift.
  • Eliminates 78% concentration risk in single property.
  • Frees management time and reduces void/repair risks.

Timing: Market property for sale in April 2025 to complete by October 2025. This:

  • Uses 2025/26 CGT exemption if sale straddles tax years
  • Avoids remortgage at predicted 5.5%+ rates in 2026
  • Crystallises gains before potential CGT rate increases (Labour policy risk)

CGT Calculation:

  • Estimated gain: £295,000 - (£140,000 + £15,000 purchase costs) = £140,000
  • Letting relief: £40,000 (if previously main residence, needs verification)
  • Combined CGT exemption (2024/25): £6,000 (reducing to £3,000 in 2025/26)
  • Spouse transfer: Transfer 50% ownership to spouse pre-sale to utilise both allowances
  • Taxable gain: £140,000 - £40,000 - £6,000 = £94,000
  • CGT at 18%/28%: Estimate £26,320 (reducible with professional valuation/spouse transfer optimisation)

Capital Redeployment:

  • Net proceeds: £155,000 - £26,320 CGT = £128,680
  • Invest: £60,000 into ISAs (2024/25 & 2025/26 allowances), £68,680 into pension (immediately attracting 60% relief = £41,208 net cost)

Risk Warning: Property market timing is uncertain. Disposal costs (legal, agent fees) 2-3% will reduce net proceeds. Mortgage early repayment charges must be checked.


7. ESTATE PLANNING

Current Net Estate: £986,000
Allowances (2024/25):

  • Nil Rate Bands: £650,000 (2 × £325,000)
  • RNRB (if qualifying): £350,000 (2 × £175,000) – dependent on children inheriting residence
  • Total allowances: £1,000,000
  • Potential IHT liability: £0 (if RNRB fully available)

However: RNRB tapers above £2m estate. If property values increase 3% pa, by age 85 estate may exceed £2m, losing RNRB. Long-term IHT risk remains.

Immediate Actions:

  • Will Review: Update to incorporate discretionary will trusts for nil-rate band on first death, securing £325,000 outside estate.
  • Lasting Powers of Attorney: Establish LPAs for Property & Financial Affairs and Health & Welfare without delay. Cost: £164 registration fee + £500 legal advice. This is critical – without LPAs, Court of Protection deputyship costs >£5,000 and 9-month delay.

Medium-term (5-10 years):

  • Regular Gifting: Utilise £3,000 annual exemption plus surplus income exemption. Gift £3,000 pa to children's bare trusts for house deposits (7-year PET rule).
  • Discounted Gift Trust: Invest £100,000 from property sale proceeds into DGT for IHT efficiency after 7 years, providing 5% tax-deferred withdrawals for retirement.

Long-term (post-60):

  • Loan Trust: Lend £200,000 to discretionary trust for grandchildren, IHT-free after 7 years while retaining access to capital.

Risk Warning: Gifting is irrevocable. DGTs involve complexity and setup costs (£2,000). 7-year survivorship rule applies; insurance (Gift Inter Vivos) can mitigate but costs 1-2% of gift value.


8. PROTECTION REVIEW

Cover Sum Assured Adequacy Gap
Life Insurance £400,000 4× salary; marginal £600,000 shortfall for mortgage/debt clearance
Critical Illness £200,000 Covers 2 years' expenses Insufficient for long-term disability

Critical Gap: NO INCOME PROTECTION. This is your highest priority.

Income Protection (Essential):

  • Executive Income Protection: £3,500/month benefit (65% of net income), index-linked, own occupation, 26-week deferred period, payable to age 65
  • Premium: £140/month (deductible as business expense if self-employed via LLP/Directorship)
  • Why essential: 1 in 5 workers suffer >3 months' absence; your £950 mortgage + £350 car finance = £1,300/month fixed costs require protection

Life Insurance Top-up:

  • Additional Decreasing Term: £250,000 over 18 years to match primary mortgage. Cost: £18/month
  • Place in discretionary trust to avoid estate, ensure swift payout

Critical Illness Enhancement:

  • Supplementary policy: £100,000 level term to 65, covering children to age 23. Cost: £32/month

Total Additional Premium: £190/month (£2,280 pa), affordable from surplus.

Risk Warning: Pre-existing conditions may affect premiums. Own occupation definition essential; budget definition unsuitable. Reviewable premiums increase with age – guaranteed premium option costs 30% more initially.


9. TAX EFFICIENCY REVIEW

Current Position: Your £97,000 gross income triggers 60% marginal rate between £100,000-£125,140 (personal allowance taper).

Strategy:

  • Pension contributions of £12,750 gross restore full personal allowance, saving £6,120 tax
  • Effective cost: £6,630 net for £12,750 pension investment (108% immediate uplift)

Child Benefit High Income Charge: Your income >£60,000 triggers full charge. Consider:

  • Reduce income to £60,000 via salary sacrifice pension, saving £2,636 Child Benefit + £10,631 tax = £13,267 net benefit

  • Action: Dispose of BTL in 2025/26, crystallising gains across two tax years to maximise allowances (£3,000 each year)

  • GIA harvest: Sell and rebuy £3,000 of GIA holdings annually to utilise CGT exemption

  • Fully utilise ISA wrapper to eliminate dividend tax

  • Premium Bond winnings tax-free

  • Spouse's savings allowance (£1,000) and dividend allowance (£500) should be maximised by transferring GIA assets to her

  • See Section 7 for gifting and trust strategies

  • Business Relief qualifying investments (AIM ISA) can achieve IHT exemption after 2 years but carry high risk – unsuitable for your risk profile

Risk Warning: Tax rules change. Labour's manifesto proposed ALIGNING CGT rates with income tax and restricting pension relief. Fixed protection may be advisable if lifetime allowance reintroduced.


10. CASH FLOW MODELLING

Age Event Projected Net Worth Pension Fund Monthly Income
45 Current £986,000 £227,000 £7,462
52 Child 1 university £1,450,000 £410,000 £7,800
55 Child 2 university £1,680,000 £580,000 £8,100
60 Retirement £2,050,000 £1,115,000 £4,333*
67 State Pension £2,300,000 £850,000 £5,950**

*Drawdown £30,000 pa + ISA income
**State Pension £23,000 + reduced drawdown

Assumptions: 5% investment return, 2.5% inflation, 3% property growth, implemented recommendations.

Downside Scenario (3% returns, 4% inflation, BTL void 6 months):

  • Retirement fund: £920,000 (shortfall of £195,000)
  • Required: Work to 63 or reduce expenditure by £800/month

Upside Scenario (6% returns, 2% inflation):

  • Retirement fund: £1,380,000
  • Excess enables £100,000 house deposit gifts at 65

Stress Test: 20% equity market fall at age 58 reduces fund to £890,000. Recovery plan: Reduce drawdown to £25,000 for 3 years or delay retirement 12 months.

Risk Warning: Cash flow modelling is illustrative. Actual outcomes depend on market performance, regulatory changes, and personal circumstances. Annual review essential.


11. IMPLEMENTATION ROADMAP

  1. Apply for Income Protection – cannot overstate urgency

  2. Instruct solicitor for LPA preparation – register both types

  3. Contact mortgage broker – check BTL ERC and remortgage options vs sale

  4. Book Will review – with STEP-qualified solicitor

  5. Increase pension contributions via salary sacrifice to 15% (client) and 10% (spouse) – effective next payroll

  6. Open new SIPP for pension consolidation – initiate transfer paperwork

  7. Open dedicated University ISA – set up £550 monthly direct debit

  8. Transfer £35,000 GIA into ISAs – sell and rebuy via Bed & ISA process

  9. Market BTL property – aim for Q2 2025 completion

  10. Implement Gift Inter Vivos insurance (£150,000 cover, 7 years) if gifting strategy adopted

  11. Establish discounted gift trust (post-property sale) – £100,000

  12. Review and switch investment platforms – to lowest-cost providers

  13. Rebalance portfolios quarterly

  14. Harvest CGT exemptions each April

  15. Review protection sums assured for inflation

Cost Summary: Implementation costs £3,500 (legal fees) + £190/month additional premiums + £7,650 net pension cost = £12,380 Year 1 cash flow impact, fully affordable from surplus.


12. ONGOING SERVICE & REVIEW

  • Annual Review Meetings: October each year (aligns with tax year planning)
  • Interim Reviews: On any material change (job, health, legislation)
  • Portfolio Rebalancing: Quarterly automated review, rebalanced if drift >5%
  • Cash Flow Model Update: Annually with actual returns and revised assumptions

We recommend our "Chartered Wealth Management" service:

  • Holistic annual review (2-3 hours)
  • Unlimited email/telephone support
  • Quarterly portfolio valuations
  • Real-time cash flow modelling access via client portal
  • Annual fee: 0.75% of assets under advice (minimum £1,500 pa)

Independent vs Restricted: We are independent, enabling whole-of-market product selection with no provider bias.

  • Legislative Risk: Monitor Labour tax reforms, pension allowance changes, CGT rate alignment

  • Concentration Risk: Track property % of net worth (target <50% post-sale)

  • Sequence Risk: Dashboard alert if portfolio falls >10% in any year

  • Mortgage Risk: Rate alert 6 months before fixed-rate expiry

  • Immediately inform us of any material changes to health, employment, or objectives

  • Maintain LPA and Will safe custody and notify attorneys

  • Execute investment transactions within 30 days of recommendation

  • Provide annual expenditure updates for cash flow model


DECLARATION OF SUITABILITY

This report is based on the information you provided on [date]. The recommendations are suitable for your stated balanced risk profile and objectives. The financial products suggested are selected on a whole-of-market basis with no commission or provider incentive.

Key Risks You Must Understand:

  1. Investment Risk: Your capital can fall, and you may get back less than invested. 5% returns are not guaranteed.
  2. Tax Risk: Rules may change, affecting reliefs and allowances.
  3. Property Risk: Sale values and timing are uncertain.
  4. Protection Risk: Insurers may decline claims for non-disclosure; full medical underwriting required.

Cancellation Rights: Pension and investment products have 30-day cancellation rights. Protection policies have 30-day 'cooling off'. BTL sale and legal work are binding.

Next Steps: Please read this report carefully. We will schedule a 90-minute meeting to answer questions. Implementation will only proceed after your signed authority.

Yours faithfully,

[Your Name], Chartered Financial Planner, FPFS

Firm: [Firm Name] | FCA Number: [XXXXXX]
Contact: [Tel/Email]


Appendices Available on Request:

  • A. Key Features Documents for Recommended Products
  • B. Investment Risk Questionnaire Reconfirmation
  • C. Cash Flow Model Assumptions and Scenarios
  • D. Provider Due Diligence Summary
  • E. Fees and Charges Disclosure (Initial and Ongoing)
LINK COPIED!